Location: Aruba
Order: Patacon con queso (basically plantains with cheese on top), 2 Empanadas, Red snapper (fried whole), Mojito
Price: $39
Positives: Very large selection, mojito was awesome (these are harder to get in the island than I thought), snapper was really good, price point is great
Negatives: Service is a bit slow, cheese on the patacon wasn’t melted at all (not sure if this was intentional or not)
tldr: Good place to get some cheap seafood or Columbian and they have a killer mojito
Thoughts: The start of our dining experience at Don Jacinto’s was a little confusing honestly. The menu was entirely in Spanish and our waiter was having just a bit of a harder time translating some of it into English for us. Eventually we got an English menu with helped a considerable amount so if you aren’t awesome with some of the more uncommon food related words in Spanish then maybe just ask for the English menu. It helped us narrow down what we wanted a bit better.
We ended up ordering a mojito, patacon con queso, two empanadas and then a whole red snapper. We would just share the appetizers and the main dish since neither of us were that hungry. The mojito was delicious and great example of a good mojito. I mention this only because I found the mojito wasn’t as common of a drink as I thought it would be for an island where everyone serves drinks and rum is super common. I think it might be that mint is probably the rare ingredient in this dish but I’m not sure.
The pataocon was actually a little disappointing, I’m not sure if it was an intentional decision but the cheese on top of the plantains wasn’t melted at all. Basically someone just sprinkled shredded white cheese on top of plantains and it ended up resulting in a dry dish. If that is how they meant to serve it, I think I’d try asking if I could get them to bake the dish for three to five minutes just to melt that delicious cheese. The empanadas were great though, the beef inside them was really well seasoned, not the dry flavorless meat crumbles that you sometimes get in empanadas. I was impressed that they paid just as much attention to the filling of the empanada as they did the dough.
The winner here though was the red fish. It was fried whole and served just the same, leaving you to pick the flaky fish off the bone. The fish was smaller than some I’ve seen which left it perfect for a single serving, in the past fish served this way is often so big you really need two people to finish it. Fortunately, this wasn’t the case because my wife had decided she was full right as I dove into the snapper. The snapper was pretty good but a little over-fried in my opinion, it left the fish just a little dry in places where the fish wasn’t as thick, and the crunch was a bit more like. The taste of the fish was there just a little overwhelmed by the crunchiness of the fish skin and dryness of some of the smaller chunks.
Don Jacinto was a good, if not quite great, restaurant. Their stand outs were the whole red snapper and the mojito. It is incredibly affordable for everything you get, and their mojito was on point. While it wasn’t my favorite restaurant it is good and affordable, and I’d go back for sure if I lived here.